There isn’t much innovation going in here. So, how big of a fan are you?

There’s not enough rain in Oklahoma to rid the feeling that she’s sung these songs many times before.

It’s more of the same from Carrie Underwood, so full of a predictable kind of pleasantness.

Carrie Underwood takes a ride down the formulaic lane.

Easily the best American Idol alumnus album to date, which means it’s pleasant and we still have some way to go.