Return To Promise
by Debbie Macomber, contemporary (2000)
MIRA, $12.00, ISBN 1-55166-613-8

What a colossal waste of time and money. Return To Promise tells of a marriage falling apart and uprighting itself again at the end. But since this is a romance, we can't alienate some readers who may object to real reasons why a couple drift apart, right? So, we can't have financial problems, infidelity, stupid in-laws (old people must be dotty and fun according to this author), or any credible reason that would make me accept why a couple would drift apart so easily.

So instead, we have Jane Peterson screaming at her husband Cal incessantly because:

(a) He takes part in a rodeo behind her back, and

(b) He is too chicken-shit to tell her that he has an intimate dinner with an ex while Jane was away.

Minor misunderstandings that can be cleared up in a moment, of course, if these two morons practise "emotional honesty" that TV woman Barbara de Angelis always preaches about. He can't tell her, she won't listen, and I scream at them, "Just freaking kill each other and let the story end, for crimminy's sake!"

I gave up babysitting a hundred years ago, and I have no patience for bickering kids who break up and get back together again for the most trivial of reasons.

The author wants to write a "cute" reconciliation story. Too bad no one thinks to inform her that only Sweet Valley High brats can do this break-up-today-back-together-again-tomorrow nonsense nowadays and get away with it.

Rating: 06

My Favorite Pages

This book at

This book at Amazon UK

Search for more reviews of works by this author:

My Guestbook Return to Romance Novel Central Email